login vsi company logo login vsi company logo 250x40

 

Get the best possible VDI performance, density and availability with Login VSI
Our Solutions

  • Home
  • Blog
  • Is Amazon WorkSpaces (AWS) like a cheap wine?

Is Amazon WorkSpaces (AWS) like a cheap wine?

Login VSI Performance Test: Amazon offers Desktop-as-a-Service (DaaS) with Amazon Workspaces. In this article, we test the performance of this Daas and review its pro's and con's, whilst looking at other solutions, all over a glass of wine!

For a while now Amazon has offerered Desktop-as-a-Service (DaaS) in what they call Amazon WorkSpaces.

At Login VSI, we always wondered, how well do these desktops perform? At the time of writing, we’ve been investigating the performance for a week. The whole Amazon WorkSpaces user-experience felt like choosing a cheap wine at the supermarket.

Spoiled for choice, looking for new DaaS Workspace providers

If you are looking for a new workspace there are a lot of DaaS providers. Choosing one is like buying a bottle of wine at the supermarket: you never know what you're going to get, but once you find a nice brand, you still have to choose between a red, a white or even a rosé.

Is Amazon Workspaces (AWS) like buying a cheap wine?

The same happens at one of the biggest DaaS providers: Amazon WebServices (AWS). The Chardonnay of the DaaS providers.

A workspace from the cloud is ideal. No need for #VDILIKEAPRO engineers. Even a newby can set it up. But what flavors should I choose? And do my applications always perform as I’ve come to expect from SaaS (Software as a Service) providers?

I chose a cheap wine at Amazon Workspaces (AWS) - Microsoft Office options

Tasting the performance of the DaaS environment

So, let’s give it a go! I ordered one bottle, the Standard Plus desktop, to measure the performance of the DaaS environment. At first, Amazon WorkSpaces made me really happy. My desktop was setup in less than 20 minutes. And the delivered single-user Windows Server 2008R2, with desktop experience, gave me the ability to change almost everything. If you are wondering why it’s still 2008R2, well that’s Microsoft's licensing. You can get around that by bringing your own licenses but then you need to subscribe for at least 200 desktops…a bit much for my research.

I chose a cheap wine at Amazon Workspaces (AWS) - Application metrics

Application metrics

To measure and guard the performance in the Amazon DaaS environment, I setup Login PI. With the multi-tenancy ability in Login PI I could measure the performance of my desktops from anywhere in the world. My simulated user was running before lunch and I could already show the first results to my #VDILIKEAPRO colleagues, so far so good.

The taste testing for Amazon WorkSpaces continues...

Rome wasn't built in a day, so I let my simulated user run overnight. The next day I was a bit shocked. Looking at the graph (Avg. application start time for the last 24 hours), it was showing that the start-up times, on average, of the applications where multiplied by ten!

I chose a cheap wine at Amazon Workspaces (AWS) - avg. application start time

Avg. application start time for the last 24 hours

Not only did the application start times go through the roof, but also the logon times reached a maximum of 200 seconds.

I chose a cheap wine at Amazon Workspaces (AWS) - login information

Login information from the last 24 hours

Imagine what you can do in 200 seconds. Even the trailer of Netflix series Narco’s is shorter. Luckily rebooting the machine via the Amazon WorkSpaces (AWS) console was easy. This solved the issue for a few hours. When watching the full episode of Narco’s, together with glass of wine, I could directly see in my live dashboard that the performance dropped again.

I chose a cheap wine at Amazon Workspaces (AWS) - application start time

Application start time for the last hour

Technical Support from an Amazon WorkSpaces Sommelier

I didn’t want to give up on Amazon WorkSpaces that quickly, so I tried to get some technical support from AWS. Why is the performance dropping so much? What did they do in their environment?  Unfortunately, the support was limited and not available for my Basic Support Plan.

i chose a cheap wine at amazon workspaces aws technical support

Well, what can I expect for $52? That I can get an Amazon WorkSpaces technical engineer on the phone for this amount of money? A desktop in the cloud is maybe not something you grab out of the store. For a good wine, you also ask for advice from a professional. I chose a cheap wine and took a guess at Amazon Workspaces. Who can help me turn this bad wine into a good wine?  What tweaks should I use for my Amazon WorkSpaces? Maybe the minimum of 200 Windows Desktop OS BYOL or the future desktop delivery from VMware on Amazon WorkSpaces can satisfy me?

Needless to say, my quest to run a cheap but reliable desktop from the cloud does not stop here. I am committed to getting this to work as expected. You will read more on that in my next articles. Not just for AWS. A competition has been started at the #VDILIKEAPRO office, so other providers will also be tested soon. Stay tuned!

 


 

Start using Login VSI today

Our industry-standard software is built to help you avoid problems, lower costs and improve performance. Request a Quote or get your (free!) Trial below, and benefit from our award-winning services.

Request a Quote  Request a Trial

 


 

About the author

Jasper Geelen (@jaspergeelen) has a background in ICT and joined Login VSI as a pre-sales engineer in 2015. He loves drinking a lot of coffee (some might call him an addict). In his spare time, Jasper enjoys a beer and he is part of a football / soccer team. He also coaches a team of younger football players.


Tags: Login VSI, Login PI, Microsoft, #VDILIKEAPRO, Monitoring, Windows, DaaS, Desktop Delivery, Amazon, Application Start Times, Multi Tenancy, Cloud, SaaS, Virtual Desktop, User Experience

Popular Blogs

Login VSI Blog - Ongoing Effects CPU Flaws

The Ongoing Effects of Intel CPU Flaws

The Ongoing Effects of Intel CPU Flaws Over the last year, we’ve seen many Intel CPU hardware flaws come to light and when news first broke about Meltdown & Spectre there was a lot of panic: "should we patch?", "What’s the performance impact?", "Can we still rely on this hardware?" Continue Reading
Login VSI Blog - How-To Update, Protect Against RIDL, Fallout MDS Vulnerability

How-To: Update, Protect Against RIDL, Fallout MDS Vulnerability

RIDL & Fallout MDS vulnerabilities, impact on VDI performance & actions to take. FAQs we’re receiving & updates on performance tests executed to patch flaws Intel calls “Microarchitectural Data Sampling (M.D.S.)” aka: Rogue In-Flight Data Load (RIDL), Fallout, ZombieLoad & Store-to-Leak Forwarding. Continue Reading
Login VSI Blog - Teaser Image - A Practical Guide to VDI Change Management - Part 1

A Practical Guide to VDI Change Management

Part 1: IT Change Management in general The first in an 8-part series, this practical guide to VDI Change Management will guide you through the transformation of the IT department from a back-end function into a core competency for every modern organization. Continue Reading
Login VSI - Blog - Login PI Blog Teaser Image - Windows Virtual Desktop: How To Monitor User Experience With Login PI

Windows Virtual Desktop – How to Monitor User Experience?

Microsoft has just announced the public preview of their new Windows Virtual Desktop (WVD) offering at Microsoft Ignite on Tour in Amsterdam today. For those of you who’ve not followed the rumors or the private beta, here’s the outline... Continue Reading
A Practical Guide To VDI Change Management, Part 3

A Practical Guide to VDI Change Management

Part 3: Change Accelerates with Windows 10 The third in an 8-part series, this practical guide to VDI Change Management gives you the low-down on the what, why and how of Windows 10 updates and changes Continue Reading
Login VSI Blog - Teaser Image - A Practical Guide to VDI Change Management - Part 2

A Practical Guide to VDI Change Management

Part 2: Why VDI is very sensitive to change The second in an 8-part series, this practical guide to VDI Change Management highlights the importance of effective Change Management. With all the complexities of VDI environments, any failure can severely impact your business. Continue Reading
Cookie Settings